Two Gluten-Free Apple Pies, Different Experiences
Whisked Gluten-Free Bakery offers two apple pies that look similar but deliver distinct textures and flavors. The Apple Crumble Pie features a sweet crumble topping over slow-roasted apples, while the Roasted Apple Pie uses a traditional pastry crust brushed with an egg wash. Both are gluten-free, frozen for shipping, and reheat in the oven, but they suit different preferences.
Key Differences at a Glance
The main difference is the crust and topping. The Apple Crumble Pie uses a vegan shortbread crust with a sweet oat crumble, while the Roasted Apple Pie uses a butter-based pastry crust brushed with egg wash. This affects texture, dietary suitability, and reheating time.
- Crust and Topping: Apple Crumble Pie: gluten-free shortbread crust with a crumble topping made from organic gluten-free oats, millet flour, and vegan butter. Roasted Apple Pie: traditional pastry crust (butter, vinegar) brushed with egg wash (egg yolks).
- Dietary Notes: Apple Crumble Pie is vegan (uses plant-based butter, no eggs). Roasted Apple Pie contains butter and egg wash, so it is not vegan or dairy-free. Both may contain dairy and eggs in the facility.
- Reheating Instructions: Apple Crumble Pie: reheat from frozen at 350°F for about 30 minutes. Roasted Apple Pie: reheat from frozen at 350°F for about 40 minutes. Both on a baking tray.
- Serving Suggestions: Both pies are recommended served warm with vanilla ice cream. The Roasted Apple Pie is also suggested with aged cheddar cheese.
What Each Pie Contains
- Apple Crumble Pie 9": Apple Crumble Pie: slow roasted apples in a gluten-free shortbread crust topped with sweet crumble. Ingredients include vegan butter, organic cane sugar, organic coconut sugar, and gluten-free oats. The vegan butter and oat crumble make this pie suitable for those avoiding dairy and eggs. The crumble topping adds a crunchy, crisp-like texture.

Apple Crumble Pie 9" - Roasted Apple Pie 9": Roasted Apple Pie: old fashioned apple pie with a butter-based pastry crust brushed with egg wash. Ingredients include butter, vinegar, and organic cane sugar. The traditional crust and egg wash give a classic pie texture and golden finish, but it contains dairy and eggs, so it's not vegan.

Roasted Apple Pie 9"
Which Pie Should You Choose?
Choose the Apple Crumble Pie if you want a vegan, dairy-free option with a crunchy oat crumble topping. It reheats faster (30 minutes) and has a flavor similar to apple crisp. Choose the Roasted Apple Pie if you prefer a classic, buttery pastry crust and don't need to avoid dairy or eggs. Both are gluten-free and frozen for up to 2 months, so you can buy ahead for holidays or gatherings.



